To finish off day two of our webinar, it's always great to hear from Rudi Filipek-Vandyck from FNArena.
Now, Rudi has an interesting question that he's posed to us today.
Ask yourself, are you a bearish bull or a bullish bear?
Can't wait to hear what Rudi is going to talk to us about.
Over to you, Rudi.
Hi.
I want to talk about bear markets.
I don't want to scare anyone away.
I'm not here to talk doom and gloom or talk the market into the deal of nothing.
But I do think we need to start talking about what is actually happening in the market in 2026.
And there are lots of definitions out there, ones that I do not subscribe to.
But the whole definition about bear market is sometimes it serves a purpose.
It serves a purpose because it can explain investors.
what the dynamics are, what the direction, like the use of markets, and also what is the possible outcome.
So traditionally, bear markets are always associated with very bad periods for the share market and for hazards and jump.
So they fall a lot, they cause a lot of damage, and they literally rip the heart out of everyone who's in those markets.
Think about, albeit briefly, the GFC period of 2020.
We've had the big Nasdaq meltdown after 2000.
In between, we had the GFC between late 2007 and March 2009.
And further back, we have the 1987 sell-off, the 1930s, et cetera, et cetera.
But maybe those concepts of a bear market, they no longer apply.
We get a more modernized version of it.
And there are people out there, I haven't invented any of this, although
It does correspond with my own observations.
There are people out there who have developed this concept of a walling bear market.
It basically means you don't see it anymore at the top of the market in the index.
But what happens is section after section after section underneath the top of the market is being hit by bear market conditions.
And so they de-rate.
They don't go for a while and they literally take the appetite away from investors and they lose their patience.
And ultimately they spring back to life.
And there are easily some examples that can be mentioned.
Probably the one that comes to mind is healthcare after the COVID epidemic ended in 2021, 2022.
And you can see that in Australia from share prices, for example, CSL, Cochlear, ResMed, Ramsey Healthcare, Helios, Sonic Healthcare and others, for years, they didn't go anywhere and they ultimately ended a lot lower than where they were four, five, six, seven years ago.
Now, the good news of healthcare is that that bear market might've ended in August this year.
And that too, you can see on the lot of share prices that have, some of them have gone up quite dramatically.
Think Ramsey Healthcare, think CSL, even Cochlear and ResMed are now a lot higher.
So there's two parts to the bear market.
There's the bad part and there's also the part that we should remember.
We said by the time that is over that process, then we have cheap beaten down share prices that can sometimes be quite quickly generate oversized returns.
Now in Australia, if we look back at what happened over the past two years or so, we had a big switch in sentiment and big switch in momentum.
for the, for those technology stocks and those marketing leaders up until mid 2025.
And then we had a very big flip into at the time, resources stocks that up until that point, arguably it can be argued at their own little bear market.
And since then,
technology, software, AI related, that really hasn't gone anywhere in Australia.
But it has become worse.
We also have seen nothing in 2026 in terms of small caps, for example, in general terms.
So there's always exceptions.
Up until this point, and we're now very, very, very far in 2026, we're closing towards the end of the year.
It doesn't look too bad from the index where we're slightly positive.
You add some dividends on top of that.
For some of them, you might actually have ranking and it doesn't seem to be like such a bad year, but underneath the surface, about 70% of the ASX 200 is a negative territory for the year.
And that's something we haven't really experienced that often.
But there's one period that comes to my mind that in a way is comparable.
And that's the period between May 2015 and 2016.
And what you will find, if you don't remember, you can look this up, is that share prices in the banks, in the major resources stocks, they sort of peaked in May 2015 and they only get one way going down until well into 2016.
And then also in the second, that is a period, by the way, that all the fund managers, all the stockbrokers, all the investors were complaining in the AFR and elsewhere about the expensive defensives, that those were the only ones that performed in those days, including some of our better known healthcare stocks, the quality stocks, and all the rest wasn't performing, frustrating many, many investors.
It didn't last, second half of 2016, very big violent flip and the parts of the market that weren't performing, they came to life.
Now that might be in itself something that we should all bear in mind here because let's have a look at what potentially has held back 70% this year in the Australian share market.
So I would nominate
The CCG changes proposed by this government, it has scared people away, if not forced to liquidate portfolios, to move out of small caps, et cetera, et cetera.
It has had an impact.
And of course, we've also had the persistently high inflation, actually it became worse, inflation started to go up again, forcing the Reserve Bank to start tightening again, bond yields moved up internationally as well.
Those are all elements that have a downward impact on equities in general, but in particular on bond proxies in the market that also includes technology stocks, by the way, but also everything that's related to the local housing markets, everything that's related to consumer spending.
And we've also had earnings forecasts in Australia.
earnings growth here is already lower than in overseas markets, in most of them.
And we are still going through a downtrend in Australia.
The downtrend really exerted itself in August bottom season.
Post-August, it just kept on going on.
What we've seen is that
Resources companies disappoint because of weather, but most of all because of costs, diesel, very important input data.
So you see constantly analysts recalibrating their forecast for that sector.
Equally, the banks, as we are going, as we are witnesses as well in the current polling season, they are not shooting the lights out.
And even though it's not spectacular, again, forecasts are being pared back.
And then clearly we saw from retailers and consumer spending related companies that consumerist is not really in an buoyant mood.
And again, we see those forecasts going downward, south.
Now that process might not necessarily end anytime soon.
We still get the February report and see, of course, we'll have to see, but traditionally share markets, they can find
solid bottom from the moment that those forecasts start, stop falling at the moment that's not, that's not playing out yet in Australia.
However, this is not just a bad news, not a bad news story because what we see since September as well is that in my observation, what I think is happening is that at the very least institutional investors are starting to look forward
to the time that the RBA is no longer raising numbers.
We've just had one, well, with the update.
Even if we get another one in early next year, hopefully, maybe not, then that will, by general consensus, probably be the last one.
But that means that investors who invest on the two to three year horizon, they start looking forward to the end of the tightening cycle.
And that's what you see in the share market already, I believe.
Another element that has held back Australia is this big AI trade overseas that has sort of fallen a little bit into troubles at the moment.
That has helped Australia as well.
The input I have become aware of is that international investors have again started looking at Australia as the alternative for the AI trade that's formed by the wayside internationally.
So, irrespective of our own strategies, whether we are impatient or not, whether we're in the market, out the market, besides the market, and whatever our aspirations are for next year and beyond, I think, personally, the main takeaway, what history shows us, and what seems to be happening underneath the surface in Australia, is that this too shall end at some point.
and will not last forever.
And I think that is the message to take on board for the next year.
Thank you to Rudi for his presentation.
Understanding what is happening beneath the surface of the Australian share market may help investors make sense of 2026. Presented by Rudi Filapek-Vandyck from FNArena and hosted by Darren Connolly, this video asks whether you are a bearish bull or a bullish bear.
Rudi begins by discussing the traditional idea of a bear market, as seen in past periods such as the dot-com meltdown and the GFC, and explains why he thinks a more modern version may be at work. He describes the idea of a walking bear market, where the index may look steady while one section of the market after another comes under pressure, and uses the healthcare sector as an example of a recent bear market.
The webinar then looks at what held back much of the Australian market in 2026, including proposed tax changes, persistent inflation, rising bond yields, Reserve Bank tightening, softer earnings forecasts and cautious consumer spending. Rudi compares the current period with 2015 and 2016 and discusses signs that some investors may be looking ahead to the end of the rate tightening cycle.

