Are you an investor or a gambler? In truth, you may be both.
Australians lost $36 billion on gambling in the year to March 2026, $1,290 for every person in the country. Most of those punters knew the odds were against them. They bet anyway. What they bought was hope rather than a prudent prospect of generating a return.
The same impulse often rears its head in the way investors shape their portfolios, from the speculative stock tip to the leveraged ETF to the star fund manager whose remarkable track record appears destined to continue forever.
Understanding what hope costs, and when it is worth paying for, may be one of the most valuable lessons investors can learn.
Key Takeaways
Hope is a product with a price: lottery-like investments, from longshot bets to speculative stocks, have historically underperformed on average.
Hope distorts investors’ behaviour, encouraging them to hold losers and chase winners.
The odds of picking a winning active manager are long: 88% of Australian equity general funds lagged their benchmark over 10 years to June 2026.
Lessons from the investment masters separate ‘bad hope’ (a wish for a big win) from ‘good hope’ (patient confidence in long-run compounding).
The practical solution is to ring-fence a small, pre-defined slice of your portfolio for speculative ideas and build the rest based on evidence.
Explore 100s of investment opportunities and find your next hidden gem!
Search and compare a purposely broad range of investments and connect directly with product issuers.
Strange but true: Australians spend more on lottery tickets each year than on books, cinema tickets, recorded music and video games combined.
The rational question is: why?
In short, most of us should have spent more time studying probabilities at school.
But at a deeper level, lottery tickets are a cheap way to buy a daydream.
The same pattern is showing up in the fast-evolving prediction markets.
Bloomberg’s analysis of more than a billion trades on the prediction market Kalshi found that half of all trading volume came from bets chasing returns of 1,000% or more. This has risen above 65% of late as punters have piled into parlay bets (bets on multiple outcomes). Parlays are all about buying hope — just like lottery tickets.
The maths behind these trends is brutal.
A coin-flip bet at standard odds carries a bookmaker’s margin of around 4.5%.
String eight of them together and the chance of winning falls below 0.5%, while the expected loss on every dollar staked rises to 31%. In the same way that compounding works for equity investors, in a parlay bet it works for the house.
Each extra leg compounds the bookmaker’s edge. Source: InvestmentMarkets calculations.
Where Hope Hides in Portfolios
Hope has four notorious hiding spots within investors’ portfolios…
Lottery Stocks
Investors are not immune.
Research by Alok Kumar, Who Gambles in the Stock Market?, found that individual investors are drawn to cheap, volatile, lottery-like stocks, even though those types of stocks underperform on average.
Turan Bali, Nusret Cakici and Robert Whitelaw showed that the stocks with the most extreme recent daily gains go on to deliver lower returns, because investors overpay for the small chance of hitting the jackpot.
Hendrik Bessembinder’s landmark study found that just 4% of US-listed companies accounted for all the net wealth created by the US stock market since 1926.
Hoping to find the next big winner is an understandable human desire.
Doing so reliably is extraordinarily difficult.
Losing Positions
Hope also keeps investors in bad positions.
Terrance Odean’s study of thousands of brokerage accounts found investors were 50% more likely to sell a winning stock than a losing one, clinging to their losers in the hope of getting back to even.
A century ago, the legendary speculator portrayed in Edwin Lefèvre’s 1923 classic Reminiscences of a Stock Operator accurately diagnosed this problem: ‘It is inseparable from human nature to hope and to fear.’
His cure was to reverse both instincts: ‘Instead of hoping he must fear; instead of fearing he must hope.’
In other words, the answer is to fear that a small loss becomes a big one, and to hope that a winner keeps running.
Leveraged Bets & Hot Funds
As investment products have become more sophisticated, the opportunities for hope to abound have multiplied.
Australian leveraged ETFs now manage $2.3 billion, up from $900 million five years ago.
Global X’s strategist Marc Jocum likens them to a ‘Formula 1 car’ and warns they can become ‘wealth-destroying vehicles’ if misused.
ASIC Commissioner Simone Constant was blunter in her August 2026 warning about high-risk products sold by online brokers: ‘there is no such thing as easy money.’
ASIC has also cautioned that Australians using offshore prediction markets are more likely to lose money than make money.
Then there’s the cost of chasing hot funds.
Morningstar’s Mind the Gap 2026 study found the average US fund investor earned 8.7% p.a. over the decade to 2025, against 9.9% for the funds themselves, because money tended to arrive after rallies and leave after falls.
The more exciting the fund, the larger the return gap, as shown below.
The more exciting the fund, the bigger the behaviour gap. Source: Morningstar, Mind the Gap 2026.
Star Managers
Perhaps the most respectable form of hope is the belief that we can pick the star fund manager who will keep beating the market.
However, the SPIVA Australia Mid-Year 2026 Scorecard showed that 88% of Australian equity general funds and 94% of global equity general funds underperformed their benchmarks over 10 years.
That doesn’t mean active management is worthless. Not by a long shot. But it does mean selecting a manager should be an evidence-based decision, rather than an act of faith.
Most active funds lag over the long run. Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Australia Mid-Year 2026.
Good Hope vs Bad Hope
The message here isn’t that investors should abandon hope.
Investing is itself an act of optimism, which requires being hopeful.
However, the masters of investing are clear about the difference between the useful kind and the costly kind.
Daniel Kahneman wrote in Thinking, Fast and Slow that ‘the optimistic bias may well be the most significant of the cognitive biases.’
Yet he also called it ‘both a blessing and a risk’.
The blessing is the patience it takes to stay invested.
Warren Buffett expressed it in his 2015 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders: ‘For 240 years it’s been a terrible mistake to bet against America, and now is no time to start.’
Morgan Housel captured the same idea in 2014: ‘The core of being an optimist is knowing that if you can wait long enough, the odds of winning are in your favour.’
That’s the good kind of hope. It’s grounded in realistic expectations, diversified, and long-term in nature.
Bad hope is a wish for a quick, outsized win that ignores the actual odds.
Sir John Templeton’s famous observation that bull markets ‘are born on pessimism, grow on scepticism, mature on optimism, and die on euphoria’ is a reminder that collective hope for outsized gains, at its peak, is usually a warning sign.
Benjamin Graham’s warning in The Intelligent Investor also applies: the investor’s ‘worst enemy’ is ‘likely to be himself’.
Subscribe to InvestmentMarkets for weekly investment insights and opportunities and get content like this straight into your inbox.
There are three practical habits developed by savvy investors aiming to harness the good kind of hope and keep the bad kind in its place.
Build your portfolio’s core based on evidence.
By regularly investing in broad, low-cost Australian ETFs, global ETFs and defensive assets such as bond fund ETFs, sized to match your goals and risk profile, you are positioning yourself to compound your returns.
Give yourself a hope budget.
If you want exposure to a high-conviction theme, speculative stocks or digital assets, ring-fence a small, pre-set slice that you could afford to lose entirely.
Thematic ETFs can offer diversified exposure to higher-risk themes without betting on a single company.
Write out your rules before your emotions decide on your behalf.
When will you rebalance?
When will you sell?
What evidence would change your mind?
Invest Like an Optimist, Decide Like a Sceptic
Being full of hope remains a vital part of the investing and life journey.
However, unpriced hope is the enemy of good investing. The lottery ticket, the eight-leg parlay and the hot fund are all selling the same thing, and the evidence shows buyers consistently pay too much for it.
The investment masters reserve their optimism for the one bet with the odds on its side: patient ownership of productive assets.
Keep your hope for the long run, reserve your scepticism for the next big thing, and build a portfolio that does not need a miracle to succeed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Role Should Hope Play in an Investment Strategy?
Hope works best as long-run optimism about compounding, supported by diversification and time. It works poorly as the main reason for a short-term speculative bet, where the odds are usually stacked against the investor.
Why Do Investors Buy Lottery-Like Stocks?
Research suggests investors overweight small chances of large gains, so they are willing to overpay for stocks with jackpot-like potential. Studies by Kumar and by Bali, Cakici and Whitelaw found these stocks tend to deliver lower average returns.
What Is the Disposition Effect?
The disposition effect is the tendency to sell winning investments too early and hold losing investments too long, often in the hope of breaking even. Terrance Odean found investors were 50% more likely to sell a winner than a loser.
How Much Do Investors Lose by Chasing Performance?
Morningstar estimates the average US fund investor earned 1.2% p.a. less than their funds over the 10 years to December 2025, with the gap widest in higher-risk, volatile funds.
How Can I Invest in Speculative Ideas Without Taking Too Much Risk?
Many investors use a core and satellite approach, keeping most of their money in diversified, low-cost holdings and limiting speculative positions to a small, pre-defined portion.
Disclaimer: This article is prepared by Simon Turner. It is for educational purposes only. While all reasonable care has been taken by the author in the preparation of this information, the author and InvestmentMarkets (Aust) Pty. Ltd. as publisher take no responsibility for any actions taken based on information contained herein or for any errors or omissions within it. Interested parties should seek independent professional advice prior to acting on any information presented. Please note past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
Simon Turner is an ex-fund manager with 20 years investing experience gained at Bluecrest, Kempen and Singer & Friedlander who now writes educational content about investing and sustainability. He's also the published author of The Connection Game and Secrets of a River Swimmer.
Rising interest rates, falling house prices and persistent inflation may have left many Australians feeling pessimistic about the Australian economy, but not AMP Deputy Chief Economist Diana Mousina.
A one-page investing plan is a simple written strategy that sets out what your money is for, when you’ll need it, what you’ll own and why, how much you’ll contribute and how often, and when you’ll review it.